The Right to an Independent Chemical Test After a Georgia DUI Arrest

A breath, blood, or urine result obtained after a Georgia DUI arrest can become some of the most important evidence in the case. Yet the State does not necessarily get the only test. A driver who submits to chemical testing requested by law enforcement has a statutory right to seek additional testing from a qualified person of the driver’s own choosing.
That right can matter enormously when alcohol or drug concentrations are disputed. An independent test may provide evidence against which the State’s result can be compared, but chemical evidence changes with time. A driver cannot simply remain in custody for hours and recreate the same opportunity later. Early guidance from an experienced Georgia DUI defense lawyer can help determine whether a request was made, how officers responded, and whether delay or interference deprived the driver of a meaningful opportunity to obtain independent evidence.
Georgia Law Gives Drivers a Right to Additional Testing
O.C.G.A. § 40-6-392(a)(3) provides that a person tested at the direction of law enforcement may have a physician, qualified technician, chemist, registered nurse, or another qualified person of the driver’s choosing administer an additional chemical test or tests. The statute also requires the arresting officer to advise the person of the right to additional testing.
The independent test belongs to the driver. Police select the State’s test, while the person seeking additional testing may choose the qualified testing provider. Georgia courts have repeatedly treated that opportunity as a meaningful safeguard because it allows an accused person to obtain evidence that may confirm, contradict, or place the government’s chemical result in a different context.
An important condition applies. The statutory independent-test right follows submission to a chemical test requested by law enforcement. A driver cannot ordinarily refuse the State-administered test and still demand that police facilitate an independent test under O.C.G.A. § 40-6-392(a)(3).
A Request Does Not Need Special Legal Language
A person under arrest may be nervous, tired, confused, or unfamiliar with Georgia DUI procedure. The law does not require someone in that situation to recite a carefully drafted formula before the right to independent testing becomes relevant.
McGinn v. State involved a driver who told an officer that he knew he had a right to a blood test and wanted one. He later returned to the subject while waiting to take the State’s breath test. The Georgia Court of Appeals rejected the idea that the request was ineffective because of its timing and concluded that the officer was on notice that independent blood testing had been requested.
The court emphasized that implied-consent warnings provide information about the right; they do not require a driver to use particular words to invoke it. Once the circumstances reasonably communicate a request for independent testing, the officer’s response becomes part of the legal analysis. A recording from a patrol car or body camera can therefore be especially valuable when the officer and driver later remember the conversation differently.
Police Must Make a Reasonable Effort to Accommodate the Request
Georgia law does not make an arresting officer personally responsible for guaranteeing that an independent laboratory successfully completes a test. Officers do, however, have a duty not to prevent the driver from exercising the right, and Georgia courts require reasonable efforts to accommodate a proper request.
Reasonableness depends on the circumstances. Transportation, the driver’s chosen testing facility, availability of qualified personnel, medical treatment, distance, custody status, and the practical ability to obtain the requested test may all become relevant. An officer is not necessarily required to satisfy every demand exactly as made if circumstances make it unreasonable or impossible, but simply ignoring the request presents a very different problem.
In Fowler v. State, the driver had suffered serious facial injuries and was awaiting hospital treatment for a fractured jaw. The Court of Appeals concluded that the officer was justified in not removing him from medical care to pursue the requested breath test. The decision illustrates that courts consider the real circumstances facing the officer rather than applying the accommodation requirement mechanically.
Telling a Driver to Wait Until Release Can Defeat the Right
One of the most significant Georgia decisions concerning delay is Smith v. State. Smith requested an independent blood test after agreeing to the State’s breath test. Instead of facilitating the test while Smith remained in custody, the officer expected him to post bond and arrange testing himself after release. The independent test never occurred.
The Court of Appeals rejected that approach. Posting bond is not a prerequisite to exercising the statutory right, and an officer cannot avoid the duty to accommodate a request merely by assuming that the person will soon be released. The court suppressed the State’s breath-test result because the State failed to justify its failure to accommodate Smith’s request.
That reasoning reflects the practical nature of chemical evidence. An independent test taken near the time of the State’s test can provide meaningful comparative evidence. Hours later, alcohol may have continued to leave the bloodstream and drug concentrations may have changed. A delayed opportunity is not necessarily equivalent to the opportunity that existed while the person was still in police custody.
Police Interference Can Take More Than One Form
Interference does not have to involve an officer expressly saying, “You cannot have another test.” A request can also be frustrated through delay, misinformation, refusal to transport, or conduct that leaves the driver with no realistic way to reach a qualified testing provider.
McGinn provides a useful illustration. Rather than helping the driver act on his stated desire for a blood test, the officer responded to several of his questions by explaining why the alternatives McGinn suggested would not work. The Court of Appeals concluded that reasonable accommodation required more than simply rejecting those ideas. Once the officer was on notice of the request, some effort to facilitate a reasonable alternative was required.
A defense review can compare the officer’s written account with audio and video from the arrest, jail records, transport times, hospital information, and communications concerning possible testing facilities. A short sentence in an arrest report saying that the driver “requested an independent test” may leave out a much longer conversation about where the driver wanted to go and why the test never happened.
Timing Gives Independent Evidence Much of Its Value
Chemical evidence is inherently time-sensitive. Alcohol concentration changes as the body absorbs and eliminates alcohol, while drugs and their metabolites follow their own pharmacological timelines. An independent specimen collected reasonably close to the State’s specimen may provide a useful comparison that becomes difficult or impossible to obtain later.
The Court of Appeals made that practical point directly in Smith. The court observed that the statute contemplates an independent test while the accused remains in relatively the same state of intoxication as during the State’s testing; otherwise, much of the test’s value as competing evidence would disappear.
Preserving the resulting evidence can extend beyond obtaining the sample itself. Records identifying the collection time, testing provider, specimen, analytical method, and laboratory result may later become significant when comparing independent testing with the government’s analysis. A blood sample may also present possibilities for additional review that a fleeting breath measurement does not.
Losing the Independent Test Can Affect the State’s Evidence
Failure to obtain an independent test does not automatically exclude the government’s chemical result. O.C.G.A. § 40-6-392(a)(3) specifically provides that a justifiable failure or inability to obtain additional testing does not prevent admission of the State’s test. The court therefore examines why the independent test did not occur.
Where law enforcement prevents a requested test without adequate justification, the result can be very different. In Smith, the State-administered breath result should have been suppressed because police failed to reasonably accommodate the request. McGinn likewise resulted in reversal after the officer’s handling of an unambiguous request frustrated the defendant’s ability to obtain independent blood testing.
The State carries the burden of showing compliance with the statutory requirements and, when an independent test could not be obtained, establishing justification under the totality of the circumstances. A suppression challenge can therefore focus closely on the sequence of events rather than treating the missing independent result as an unfortunate fact that ends the inquiry.
Reconstructing What Happened After the Request
Independent-testing disputes are often decided through details that occur within a relatively short period after arrest. The exact words used by the driver, the officer’s response, completion of the State test, transportation decisions, medical issues, booking procedures, and eventual release can establish whether police provided a genuine opportunity to obtain another test.
Video and audio can be especially revealing. McGinn demonstrates how a driver’s repeated discussion of blood testing can put an officer on notice even when the request does not fit neatly into the officer’s normal sequence of implied-consent procedures. Smith shows why an officer cannot simply postpone the problem until the driver bonds out.
A careful review by an Atlanta DUI defense lawyer can determine whether the request was sufficiently clear, whether police made reasonable efforts to accommodate it, and whether the loss of time-sensitive independent evidence provides grounds to challenge the State’s chemical-test result.
Contact The Spizman Firm Today
A request for independent chemical testing can be easy to overlook amid the stress of a DUI arrest, transportation, testing, and booking. Yet the opportunity to obtain a separate blood, breath, or urine result may provide evidence that cannot be recreated after enough time has passed.
Contact The Spizman Firm today to speak with an experienced Georgia DUI defense lawyer and learn how we can examine the chemical testing, independent-test request, police response, and preservation of evidence in your Georgia DUI case.
Sources:
Georgia Code § 40-6-392 — Chemical Tests for Alcohol or Drugs
Perano v. State, 250 Ga. 704 (1983)
Smith v. State, 250 Ga. App. 532 (2001)

